Reviewed · EDINBURGH TOURS
Multi Day Private Tour Of Scotland
Scotland is a fine country for a flexible road trip, and this three-day private tour puts the route in Dave’s hands. He picks you up at your accommodation or another agreed meeting point, then takes your group out from Edinburgh with private transport and lively, plain-spoken commentary. The most appealing part is the chance to help shape the trip instead of following a packed coach schedule.
I like the small private group, which keeps the day personal and lets you travel with only your own party. I also like Dave’s flexible style, especially if you value humor, local opinions, and a guide who will tell you when a famous stop is not worth your time. The main drawback is the thin published itinerary: you know the tour leaves Edinburgh and returns three days later, but the exact stops are not set out.
In This Review
- Key points to know before booking
- A private Scotland trip with room to adjust
- Day one: leaving Edinburgh behind
- Day two: choosing substance over a famous name
- What private transportation changes
- Dave’s commentary is part of the product
- The $3,055.64 group price
- Who will enjoy this format most
- Practical questions to settle before departure
- Should you book Dirty Daves?
- FAQ
- Where does the tour begin and end?
- Can I be picked up at my accommodation?
- How many people can join the private tour?
- Is Inverness Castle included?
- What is included in the price?
- Can I cancel for a full refund?
Key points to know before booking

- Dave leads with humor and strong opinions: Expect lively commentary rather than a formal, scripted lecture.
- Your group can help shape the route: The experience is designed for private planning and flexibility.
- Pickup is offered: You can arrange collection at your accommodation or another agreed meeting point.
- The route skips Inverness Castle: Dave does not make it a featured stop because he considers it poor value.
- Up to eight people can share the vehicle: The fixed group price becomes much better value with a full party.
- The tour lasts about three days: Plan on a broad Scotland trip rather than a quick Edinburgh excursion.
A private Scotland trip with room to adjust

This experience is best understood as a private road tour, not a standard sightseeing circuit. The public plan gives only the broad shape: leave Edinburgh on the first day, spend the middle day touring Scotland, and return to Edinburgh on the third.
That lack of detail cuts both ways. You get room for your interests to influence the trip, which is useful if you already have places in mind or want to avoid stops that feel forced. At the same time, you should ask for a clear route before booking. Exact towns, attractions, driving times, meal stops, and overnight arrangements are not specified here.
Dave’s role is central. His commentary is described as funny, direct, and flexible, with a style that aims to keep the drive entertaining. If you like a guide who offers opinions rather than simply reading dates from a script, this should suit you. If you want a tightly timed program with every castle and viewpoint listed in advance, you may find the open format less reassuring.
The private setup matters in Scotland. A group of up to eight can talk freely, stop to discuss options, and avoid the social strain of a large coach. You are not sharing the day with strangers, and the whole group can make decisions together.
A few more Edinburgh trips to weigh up
- The Potter Trail Private Tour
★ 5.0 · 2,353 reviews - Private Tour of the Scottish Highlands from Edinburgh
★ 5.0 · 325 reviews - Guided Edinburgh Private Walking Tour
★ 5.0 · 269 reviews
Day one: leaving Edinburgh behind
The first day begins with pickup in Edinburgh. Collection is available at your accommodation or another prearranged meeting point, so you do not need to make your way to a large bus terminal.
That is a practical benefit, especially if you have luggage or are staying away from the city center. Confirm the meeting place clearly before the start, since the information provided does not name a standard pickup point or exact departure time.
The day is described simply as leaving Edinburgh. That may sound bare, but it reflects the tour’s custom nature. Rather than pretending there is a fixed list of stops, the experience leaves space for the route to be arranged around your group.
You should treat day one as the start of a road journey, not as an Edinburgh walking tour. The tour begins in Edinburgh, but no Edinburgh attractions are listed as part of the program. If you want time at Edinburgh Castle, the Royal Mile, or the National Museum of Scotland, plan that separately unless Dave agrees to include it.
The value of the first day lies in the transition from city to open road. You get private transportation and commentary from the start, with the chance to ask questions and make the journey feel more personal. The tradeoff is that you must be comfortable with an itinerary that is not fully spelled out online.
Day two: choosing substance over a famous name

The second day is the heart of the tour, yet it is also the least defined. One clear point is that Dave does not really take groups to Inverness Castle. His view is that the castle is not worth a major stop.
That opinion tells you something useful about the guiding style. Dave is not simply checking off famous names because they appear in a brochure. He is willing to steer you away from an attraction he considers disappointing. For many people, that is a plus. Three days in Scotland is not long, and time spent at a weak stop means less time for places that better suit your group.
Still, you should not assume that skipping Inverness Castle means skipping Inverness altogether. The available information only says the castle is not really visited. Ask Dave what the middle day includes, and confirm which places are planned before you commit.
This is where the tour’s flexible design can work well. You can tell Dave what matters to you, then use his judgment to shape the route. The supplied details do not name the alternative stops, so I would not book this expecting a guaranteed list of castles, lochs, villages, or scenic viewpoints.
The commentary may be the strongest reason to choose the tour. A private drive through Scotland can become dull if the guide says little. Dave’s style is presented as lively and funny, with enough flexibility to respond to questions and interests. That can turn long stretches between stops into part of the experience rather than dead time.
I would also listen carefully to his advice about priorities. A guide who openly dismisses one attraction may have useful opinions about other places too. You do not have to agree with every judgment, but direct advice can help you use limited time wisely.
What private transportation changes

Private transportation gives this tour a different feel from a standard group excursion. You are not bound to a large coach’s passenger list, and your group alone takes part.
That does not mean every decision is spontaneous. A three-day route still needs planning, and the exact vehicle, storage space, rest breaks, and daily driving schedule are not stated. If you have bulky luggage, mobility concerns, or a strong preference for shorter driving stretches, raise those points before departure.
The moderate physical fitness requirement is worth noting. The tour is not described as a strenuous hiking trip, but Scotland sightseeing can involve getting in and out of a vehicle and walking around attractions. You should be prepared for a normal active touring pace unless a different arrangement is confirmed.
Service animals are allowed. The tour is also near public transportation, although pickup is offered, so you have more than one way to manage the start or end of your time in Edinburgh.
Same glens and lochs, a completely different day out:
- The World Famous Underground Ghost Tour
★ 4.5 · 9,272 reviews - Underground Vaults Walking Tour in Edinburgh Old Town
★ 4.5 · 8,506 reviews - Loch Ness, Scottish Highlands, Glencoe and Pitlochry Tour
★ 5.0 · 6,854 reviews - Loch Ness & Highlands Small-Group Tour from Edinburgh with Cruise
★ 4.5 · 6,022 reviews
Dave’s commentary is part of the product

The strongest praise is aimed at Dave himself. He is described as funny, flexible, and good at shaping the day around the group. One particularly experienced customer, who has visited 78 countries over 30 years, called this the best tour and said Dave made everything enjoyable.
That is a meaningful endorsement because it focuses on the guiding, not just the scenery. Scotland has plenty of roads and viewpoints, but the quality of a private tour often rests on the person in the front seat. Dave appears to bring personality and judgment, two things a fixed audio guide cannot provide.
The phrase bad ass commentary in the tour details is informal, but it sets the tone. Expect a lively voice with opinions. This may be exactly right for you if you enjoy jokes, candid assessments, and conversation. It may be less suitable if you prefer quiet travel or a polished, academic presentation.
You should also remember that a flexible guide needs an engaged group. Tell Dave what you enjoy, what you have already seen, and what you would rather skip. The more useful information you provide, the easier it will be to make the private format work for you.
The $3,055.64 group price

The cost is $3,055.64 for a group of up to eight people. That is a substantial total, but the per-person value changes sharply with group size.
With eight people, the price works out to about $382 per person for the entire three-day experience. With four people, it is about $764 each. For two people, it is about $1,528 each. Those figures make the tour much more appealing for a family or group of friends than for a couple traveling alone.
Your payment covers private transportation and the guide’s commentary. The supplied details do not say that accommodation, meals, attraction admission, or other personal expenses are included, so ask about those items before booking. That question matters more on a three-day tour than it would on a short city excursion.
The best value comes from sharing the fixed cost while using the tour’s flexibility. A full group can receive private service without paying eight separate tour prices. A smaller party pays more for the same vehicle and guide, so you should compare the total against other private touring choices.
The fact that this experience is often booked about 75 days ahead also gives you a useful planning clue. It may be wise to reserve early, especially if your dates are fixed, but confirmation is still subject to availability and is sent within 48 hours of booking.
Who will enjoy this format most

I would consider this tour for a group that wants Scotland by road but does not want a large coach. It suits families, friends, and small parties who can agree on a general style of trip and who appreciate a guide with a strong personality.
It is also a good fit if you want help making choices. Scotland offers more possible stops than three days can hold, and Dave’s willingness to reject a weak attraction can save time. The private format gives you a better chance to focus on your group’s interests.
You may want another option if you need a fully itemized route before paying. The available plan does not list the main stops beyond Edinburgh as the start and finish, and it specifically rules out a meaningful visit to Inverness Castle.
I would also think carefully about the price if only one or two people are going. The fixed group cost is easier to justify when divided among several people. At full capacity, the economics are far better.
Practical questions to settle before departure
Ask for the proposed route, overnight plan, daily start times, and expected driving periods. Also confirm what is included beyond transport and commentary.
Tell Dave about your interests before the tour begins. The private format is most useful when the guide knows if your group prefers history, scenery, towns, food, short walks, or simply a relaxed ride with good conversation. Those specific preferences can help turn a vague three-day plan into a trip that feels made for you.
Do not assume Inverness Castle is part of the program. Dave’s stated position is that it is rubbish, so if seeing the castle matters to you, discuss that directly rather than hoping it appears on the route.
Pickup is available at your accommodation or another agreed spot. Confirmation arrives within 48 hours, subject to availability. You can cancel for a full refund up to 24 hours before the experience begins, but late cancellations and changes inside that window are not accepted.
Should you book Dirty Daves?
Book this tour if you want a private Scottish road trip with a human guide, strong commentary, and room to shape the experience. It is especially appealing for a full group of up to eight, where the fixed price becomes much easier to justify.
Pause before booking if you need a detailed, guaranteed sightseeing list or if you are traveling as only one or two people. Get the route and inclusions in writing first. If Dave’s candid humor and flexible approach sound like your kind of travel, this could be a memorable way to see more of Scotland from Edinburgh.
FAQ
Where does the tour begin and end?
The tour begins in Edinburgh and returns to Edinburgh after approximately three days.
Can I be picked up at my accommodation?
Yes. Pickup is offered at your accommodation or another prearranged meeting spot.
How many people can join the private tour?
The price covers a private group of up to eight people. Only your group participates.
Is Inverness Castle included?
No major visit to Inverness Castle is planned. Dave does not consider it worthwhile, so ask about the exact route if seeing the castle is important to you.
What is included in the price?
Private transportation and commentary from the guide are included. The available details do not specify accommodation, meals, attraction tickets, or other personal costs.
Can I cancel for a full refund?
Yes. You can cancel at least 24 hours before the local start time for a full refund. Cancellations or changes made less than 24 hours before the start are not accepted.
Just added around Edinburgh
- Half Day Sailing Trip★ 5.0 · 11 reviews
- Full Day Sailing Trip★ 5.0 · 10 reviews
- Blackness Castle Cruise★ 4.5 · 39 reviews
- Private South Queensferry Town Walking Tour★ 5.0 · 3 reviews
- Edinburgh Shore Excursion: City Tour and Royal Yacht Britannia★ 4.0 · 41 reviews
- Edinburgh Shore Excursion with a Local Guide: 100% Personalized & Private★ 4.0 · 7 reviews
- Edinburgh: West Highlands Privately Guided Day Tour in Luxury MPV★ 5.0 · 10 reviews
- Whisky Tasting at Edinburgh’s Award Winning Whiski Rooms★ 5.0 · 5 reviews
Edinburgh Tours, compared.

Underground Vaults Walking Tour in Edinburgh Old Town
Read our review →
Loch Ness, Scottish Highlands, Glencoe and Pitlochry Tour
Read our review →
Loch Ness & Highlands Small-Group Tour from Edinburgh with Cruise
Read our review →
Edinburgh Castle: Guided Walking Tour with Entry Ticket
Read our review →
Edinburgh Castle Guided Walking Tour in English
Read our review →


